Skip to content

The question

What kind of death would you consider a good one?

Originally asked

Vanity Fair, to its interview subject, The Proust Questionnaire

A fixed final question in Vanity Fair's Proust Questionnaire, repeated verbatim across respondent pages.

You answer as yourself. Nobody on FLAPSS answers as anybody else.

DA
Diana Athill

Editor and memoirist

Recorded said elsewhere, not written here
That process depends on what you are dying of. The body can fail in ways that are extremely distressing, slowly and painfully, demanding much stoicism, or it can switch off with little more than a flash of dizziness. In my family we seem to have been uncommonly lucky in that respect. There was the 82-year-old uncle who was at a meet of the Norwich Stag Hounds, enjoying a drink with friends, when crash! And he fell off his horse, dead. There was the cousin in her eighties who fell dead as she was filling a kettle to make tea, and the other cousin, 98, who slipped away so gently that the sister who was holding her hand didn’t realise that she had stopped breathing.

The Guardian, 23 September 2014 source ↗

Others on this question

View all 43 →
Gayle King Broadcaster
I’d like to die anytime after the age of 90—in my sleep!
Recorded Vanity Fair, The Proust Questionnaire, Vanity Fair, 5 July 2016 source ↗
When I’m extremely old during a huge family celebration where everyone is playing games and giving pre-written toasts … to me.
Recorded Vanity Fair, The Proust Questionnaire, Vanity Fair, 10 March 2016 source ↗
George Saunders Short-story writer and novelist
Read incorrectly, that sounds like a threat. No thanks, Vanity Fair !
Recorded Vanity Fair, The Proust Questionnaire, Vanity Fair, 25 January 2023 source ↗
Joan Rivers Comedian
Coming offstage after a five-minute standing ovation, falling into the arms of my lover, and having the doctor look at me and say, “This is impossible! She looks much too young to go!”
Recorded Vanity Fair, The Proust Questionnaire, Vanity Fair, 4 September 2014 source ↗

More from Diana Athill

View profile →
Question How close have you come to dying? Death & what remains
So, when many years later I really was near death as a result of a haemorrhage after a miscarriage, and heard a doctor saying “She’s very near collapse – call the lab and tell him to run” and understood that the “him” was the person fetching the blood they were going to pump into me, I was not in the least alarmed as I dimly wondered if I had the strength left to think some suitable Last Thought, concluded that I hadn’t, and said to myself the words: “Oh well, if I die I die.” I was sure, then, that nothingness was just that.
Recorded The Guardian, 23 September 2014 source ↗
Question What lesson has mattered most in your life? Time & hindsight
That this was true, I owe to Montaigne. I can’t remember when I read, or was told, that he considered it a good thing to spend a short time every day thinking about death, thus getting used to its inevitability and coming to understand that something inevitable is natural and can’t be too bad, but it was in my early teens, and it struck me as a sensible idea. Of course I didn’t set out to think about death in a regular way every day, but I did think about it quite often, and sure enough, it worked.
Recorded The Guardian, 23 September 2014 source ↗
Question What worries you about getting older? Time & hindsight
I saw them recently on their morning walk, and they caused me a pang. I have always wanted a pug and now I can't have one, because buying a puppy when you are too old to take it for walks is unfair. There are dog-walkers, of course; but the best part of owning a dog is walking with it, enjoying its delight when it detects the signs that a walk is imminent, and its glee when its lead is unsnapped and it can bound off over the grass, casting cheerful looks back at you from time to time to make sure that you are still in touch.
Recorded NPR, 14 December 2009 source ↗
Question When did you last change your mind about something important? Change of mind
I can’t remember when I read, or was told, that he considered it a good thing to spend a short time every day thinking about death, thus getting used to its inevitability and coming to understand that something inevitable is natural and can’t be too bad, but it was in my early teens, and it struck me as a sensible idea. Of course I didn’t set out to think about death in a regular way every day, but I did think about it quite often, and sure enough, it worked. Why coming to see death’s naturalness should have caused belief in an afterlife to melt away, I am unsure, but it did.
Recorded The Long Read essay, The Guardian, 23 September 2014 source ↗
Question Does the thought of dying frighten you? Death & what remains
These matters have become discussable with one’s friends, not, of course, as a frequent part of gossip over lunch in the dining room (our only communal occasion) but from time to time, perhaps when admiring someone’s stoicism if their frailty is becoming painfully apparent, or feeling sad at someone else’s inability to accept what seems to be imminent. As a result of this openness, I think that most of the people here would consider it foolish to be frightened of being dead. All of us, however, feel some degree of anxiety about the process of dying.
Recorded The Guardian, 23 September 2014 source ↗
Question What do you believe happens when we die? Death & what remains
The contributor to the programme I remember with the most pleasure is the man who said that not existing for thousands and thousands of years before his birth had never worried him for a moment, so why should going back into non-existence at this death cause him dismay? Everyone laughed when he said that and so did I, and as I laughed I thought: “Dead right!”
Recorded The Guardian, 23 September 2014 source ↗

More on death & what remains

Also answered this

Alice Waters, Christopher Hitchens, Joan Rivers, Diane Keaton, Ina Garten, Terry Gross

Search the directory for somebody in particular.

Explore further

Report this answer