Skip to content

The question

Whose work do you read even when you disagree with them?

Originally asked

Vox, to writers and thinkers, 9 Questions, 2017

Vox used this as one of nine fixed questions in its 2017 series on intellectual habits.

You answer as yourself. Nobody on FLAPSS answers as anybody else.

BB
Beth Breeze

Professor of Philanthropic Studies at the University of Kent

Recorded said elsewhere, not written here
We should engage with these texts. I disagree with them, and I argue back against them, but I don’t think that means they shouldn’t be read and thought about.

Sophie Roell, Five Books interview, published transcript, 29 December 2021 source ↗

Others on this question

View all 26 →
Antulio J. Echevarria II Editor of the US Army War College Quarterly
This book is a great place for people to begin who want to learn more about strategy. Gray does what he says he is going to do: he talks about modern strategy. He talks about everything from the principles of nuclear strategy to the basic fundamentals of strategy itself, the importance of Clausewitz, and of strategic context. I don’t agree with everything he says, but no strategist agrees with everything another one has to say. But his book is a great place to begin.
Recorded Sophie Roell, Five Books interview, published transcript, 23 February 2017 source ↗
Myra Strober Labor economist; professor at Stanford’s School of Education
I like the introduction where she says that ‘the solution does not lie in government regulation or getting men to do more around the house, although that would be nice.’ I disagree with her about government regulation.
Recorded Sophie Roell, Five Books interview, published transcript, 10 June 2015 source ↗
Harry Sidebottom Ancient historian and novelist; teaches ancient history at Oxford University
This is an odd choice because I disagree with almost all his conclusions. He argues that the reign of Augustus sees the Roman élite finally dealing with the problems of the Greek culture that they love and the nasty Greeks they rule. He’s just wrong. They don’t. They carry on loving the culture and despising Greeks. I don’t agree with his methods. He doesn’t argue things. He just tells you stuff.
Recorded Anna Blundy, Five Books interview, published transcript, 4 October 2010 source ↗
Henry Rollins Musician, writer and broadcaster
I’ve read Cheney’s and Bush’s autobiographies. Books by Sarah Palin and Anne Coulter. I read articles on Breitbart.
Recorded Sean Illing, Vox, “9 questions” series, 8 April 2017 source ↗

More on attention & the world

Also answered this

Ariel Rubinstein, Myra Strober, Jessica Henwick, Henry Rollins, Martha Nussbaum, Richard Wolfson

Search the directory for somebody in particular.

Explore further

Report this answer